Skip to main content

Consumer Dispute Chargebacks

A consumer dispute means the cardholder agrees they made the payment but has a problem with the purchase. This is the most common type of chargeback, and the one where good customer service makes the biggest difference.

Common codes: Visa 13.1 to 13.9, Mastercard 4841, 4853, 4855, 4859, 4860, American Express C02 to C32.

Goods or services not received​

The cardholder says they didn't receive what they paid for. This is Visa 13.1, Mastercard 4853 or 4855, and American Express C08.

Prevent it: give delivery dates at checkout, use tracked delivery, and send tracking information to the customer.

Evidence that helps: proof of delivery to the address the customer gave, ideally with a signature, or proof the customer used the service.

Not as described or defective​

The cardholder says what they received was faulty, damaged or not as described. This is Visa 13.3 and 13.5, Mastercard 4853, and American Express C31 and C32.

Prevent it: use accurate descriptions and photos, and make it easy for customers to return goods.

Evidence that helps: the product description at the time of purchase, any messages with the customer, and proof that you offered a replacement, repair or refund.

Cancelled recurring payments​

The cardholder was charged after cancelling a subscription or recurring payment. This is Visa 13.2, Mastercard 4841, and American Express C28.

Prevent it: make cancelling easy, stop charging as soon as a customer cancels, and remind customers before a free trial ends or a renewal is due.

Evidence that helps: proof the customer agreed to the recurring terms, and proof that they didn't cancel or that they cancelled after the payment.

Refund not processed or order cancelled​

The cardholder says they cancelled or returned the order, or were promised a refund, but didn't get one. This is Visa 13.6 and 13.7, Mastercard 4853 and 4860, and American Express C02, C04 and C05.

Prevent it: process refunds promptly and tell the customer when you have. Refund to the card they paid with.

Evidence that helps: proof the refund was processed, or your cancellation and returns policy and proof the customer accepted it at checkout.

General advice​

  • Talk to the customer first. Many consumer disputes start as complaints the customer couldn't get resolved. Make it easy to contact you, and reply quickly.
  • Show your policies at checkout. Ask customers to accept your terms, returns and cancellation policy before they pay, and keep a record that they did.
  • Refund if they're right. If the customer has a fair complaint, a refund costs less than a chargeback and its fees.